FROM
THE OFFICE OF STATE SENATOR KEVIN PARKER
PH:
718-434-8510
FAX:718-421-5605
CREATING NEW REVENUE
STREAMS
ANOTHER APPROACH TO THE
STATE’S FISCAL CRISIS
By Senator Kevin Parker
21st Senate
District
Ever since Gov. George Pataki presented his
proposed budget to a joint session on Jan. 8, the incessant public discussion
has been Cuts! Cuts! Cuts! After three months and traveling throughout my
district and listening to the hapless pleas of my constituents, I made a
commitment to completely eliminate this “doomsday” rhetoric from my conversation. Instead, I’ve adopted an
aggressive posture that calls for revenue “enhancers.” In short, if as the Governor has proposed that
the way to close the state’s fiscal deficit we will need a whopping 37
percent hike in SUNY and CUNY tuition; more than $1 billion in Medicaid cuts
and a $1.2 billion decrease in local school aid, then the time has come for us
to examine ways in which we can enhance the state’s revenue in this cash strapped economy.
That’s why I’m proposing that we close the budget deficit, not
by punishing the middle-class and the needy, but by asking corporate New York
and those New Yorkers of great wealth to help ease our state through its fiscal
crisis.
It is also why I’ve endorsed the Senate Democratic proposal that
will raise more than $3.4 billion in revenue, including a temporary income tax
surcharge on New Yorkers earning more than $300,000 a year and close corporate
loopholes that allow profitable companies to avoid paying their state taxes.
Also under consideration is reinstating the New York City Commuter Tax and
restoring the sales tax on stock purchases.
Taken together, these modest revenue sources will
help offset the billions of dollars in cuts proposed by the Governor in
education and health care. There are
those who say that an income tax surcharge on wealthy New Yorkers (fewer than
200,000 taxpayers will be affected) will open up class divisions in our state
and unfairly single out a group of taxpayers. But the surcharge is more than
offset by the federal government’s 2001 tax cut, which provides generous income
tax relief for wealthy New Yorkers. In addition, the state’s high property and
sales taxes take a disproportionately higher amount of income from low- and
middle-income families (11% and 12.6%) than from wealthier families (6.4%). But
these same voices are silent about the Governor’s proposal to reinstate the sales tax on clothing
purchases, and raise bus and subway fares both regressive taxes that
disproportionately affect low income New Yorkers.
New York can raise more than $1.1 billion by
closing loopholes in the tax law that allow corporations to avoid paying their
fair share of taxes. These tax law changes include strengthening the corporate
franchise tax and decoupling the federal bonus depreciation deduction to
prevent New York from subsidizing companies who relocate out of state.
Reinstating
the commuter tax would provide millions of dollars to help New York City close
its own fiscal deficit. Certainly, this is a much more acceptable option than closing fire
houses and cutting other vital services. The commuter tax was abolished in 1999
when Wall Street was fueling record surpluses for New York State and City. For
a suburbanite making a salary of $100,000, the commuter tax represents less
than one half of one percent of his or her wages, or about $450 a year.
Finally, another idea
that has been proposed is restoring a modest sales tax on stock purchases.
Prior to 1981, New York had a 5-cent sales tax in place on every stock traded
on the New York Stock Exchange. Given the volume of stocks traded today, even
restoring the rate at half the 1981 level would raise $6 billion a year for New
York State and City. The average investor in the stock market would not even
notice the tax, amounting to one-twentieth of one percent of the value of their
average holdings.
Governor Pataki is
right when he says New York stands at a crossroads. But most New Yorkers cannot
afford to travel down the road the Governor’s budget takes us, to a place where the dream of
a college education is interrupted, where middle class property owners are
taxed out of their homes, and where the average worker is asked to dig deeper
in his pocket to pay for a subway ride home or shoes for his kid, while wealthy
corporations pay no taxes. History tells us that the Governor has chosen the
wrong path to close this deficit, a course that will cause unnecessary hardship
for hundreds of thousands of working New Yorkers, diminish the quality of life
for our seniors, deny countless young students with the opportunity for a
higher education, and undermine the very economy he seeks to bolster. New
Yorkers deserve better.
-30-